Ethics

IBIA promotes the ethical development, deployment, and use of biometric and identity technologies.

Background

Biometric technologies—ranging from facial recognition and fingerprint scanning to voice authentication and keystroke dynamics—are fundamentally changing how we authenticate and verify our identity.

By binding credentials to the person rather than a password or device, biometrics offer a powerful combination of security and convenience. As biometric applications expand rapidly across sectors—from travel and financial services to law enforcement and healthcare—so too does public scrutiny based on unfounded claims of bias, fairness, surveillance, and the responsible handling of sensitive personal data.

Because these technologies rely on immutable physical and behavioral characteristics, they carry a unique set of ethical responsibilities to ensure they are developed and used in ways that respect individuals’ privacy and rights.

IBIA Position

IBIA Position

IBIA recognizes that the widespread adoption of biometrics is contingent not just on technical accuracy, but on public trust. To that end, IBIA and its Members are committed to the ethical and responsible use of biometric and identity technologies. IBIA’s ethical framework is built on five core principles:

Respecting the Person and Related Data

Developers and users should work to ensure their biometric technologies are accurate across demographic groups and are not used for discriminatory purposes. In law enforcement and national security settings, only the most accurate technologies—as validated by established third-party evaluators like the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)—should be deployed.

Transparency

Biometric technology users should communicate with individuals about what biometric information is being collected, what it will be used for, with whom it will be shared, and for how long it will be retained. Notice and consent should be provided for all but a narrowly defined set of national security and public safety situations, and communications should be in plain, accessible language.

Data Security

Developers and users should minimize data collection, encrypt data in transfer and at rest, limit system access to trained and authorized persons, and monitor data flows to prevent unauthorized transfers.

Accountability

Biometric technology users should publish privacy policies, complete Privacy Impact Assessments, submit algorithms to independent third-party testing, adhere to industry standards, and ensure that system operators are properly trained.

Problem Resolution and Redress

Regular operational performance assessments, timely system upgrades, and clear communication about data protection practices are essential. Human review of biometric match results should be maintained when making important decisions, and developers and users should accept personal responsibility for how biometric technologies are employed.

Additionally, IBIA members have endorsed an IBIA Statement of Principles and Code of Ethics, wherein members agree to use identification technologies solely for legal, ethical, and nondiscriminatory purposes; uphold the highest standards of systems integrity and database security; maintain accountability in marketing claims; and support free trade and open competition in the identification technology marketplace.

All Key Issues

The Matching Process:

This process answers the question, “Are you who you claim to be?” The user makes an identity claim (e.g., by providing a username), and the system performs a one-to-one comparison between their live biometric template and the single template stored for that specific identity. This is used for authentication, such as unlocking a device or accessing a secure account. 

This process answers the question, “Who are you?” The system performs a one-to-many comparison, searching an entire database of stored templates to find a match for the user’s live biometric template. This is used in applications like law enforcement to identify a suspect from a crime scene fingerprint, or in national ID programs to prevent duplicate registrations.